Diseases of the Nervous System
222 Art. VI.? :Author: R. BOYD, M.D. EDIN., E.R.C.P. LONDON (Late President Medico-Psychological Association).
On this important subject I liave attempted to place on record,, in a more connected form, facts and observations made during many years, and published in my statistical and other reports of the St. Marylebone Infirmary and Somerset County Asylum. In the St. Marylebone Infirmary ample opportunities were afforded for observations, particularly in reference to the comparative state of the organs and tissues after death, the diseases of both sexes, and of all ages. The facts were carefully methodised, for a term of three years, from notes taken at the time, and in- cluded 14,544 cases; of these 8,359 were attended at their own homes, being too ill or unable to attend at the infirmary as out-patients, 1,080 of them were admitted to infirmary, fever and other hospitals, and 6,185 were in-patients, treated in the infirmary.
These cases were arranged in separate tables to show the influence of age, of sex, and of season upon disease as occurring amongst the poor of this section of the metropolis. The results, of the various diseases in each sex, at four periods of life in each quarter of the year, were contained in the tables.
The class of out-patients attended at their own homes was. frequently that of persons affected with some acute disease, which for a time kept them from their usual employment. Unwilling to be separated from their families, they preferred this mode of medical relief to being admitted to the infirmary, under the hope (which was often realised) of shortly resuming their daily labour. The number of these cases admitted to the infirmary was shown in the tables.
Two-thirds of the patients admitted to the infirmary were from the workhouse. These included a great number of children from the nursery, infant and boys’ and girls’ schools, together with old cases of disease from the chronic wards,, suffering from accession of symptoms or renewed attack of their disease.
The medical staff attached to the infirmary consisted of three physicians, two surgeons, a resident physician and house- surgeon, two assistant surgeons, who prescribed for the out- patients, and attended at their own homes those unable to come to the infirmary; also three dispensers, who compounded the drugs for all classes of the sick. At that time the attendance at tlie infirmary by students was recognised by tlie various cor- porations, the same as at a medical hospital.
The out-patients were divided into three classes?those able to attend for advice at the infirmary ; those unable to attend, who were visited at their own houses; the third class consisted of the sick inmates of the workhouse, who were not so ill as to be admitted to the infirmary, their diseases being, for the most part, mild, chronic, or incurable. The average weekly number during seven years was, of those who attended for advice at the infirmary, 130; visited at home, 115; and in the workhouse, 90. In-door patients treated in the infirmary, 218. The number of out-patients visited at their own homes during- one year was upwards of 3,000. Of this number 304 were admitted into the infirmary, leaving 2,700 cases ; 244 of these were mild cases, after parturition, leaving 2,456 of the more serious and acute forms of disease. The deaths were 175, over 7 per cent, among this class of patients. The deaths in the in- firmary for the same year had been 15 per cent. Among the 304 above-mentioned admissions to the infirmary 87 died; adding them to the out-patients visited at home, the mortality among the latter would be increased to 9-|, and that in the infirmary reduced to about 13 per cent., showing a difference of 3i per cent.
A death rarely occurred among the ” out-patients attending at the infirmary.” Should their disease assume a serious aspect they were at once placed on the list of those visited at home or admitted to the infirmary.
There were upwards of 350 cases in the chronic wards in the workhouse, all more or less diseased, affected with asthma, disease of the heart, of the brain, &c., and many of them were advanced in life. The mortality of this class was about 70 in the year.
The medical expenditure averaged in seven years, for drugs and instruments nearly ?600, and wine and spirits ?200 annually. The average cost of workhouse and out-patients for these items was half that of infirmary patients. The population of the parish, according to the census of 1841, was 139,454. The average number of persons receiving parochial relief during that year was 5,679; of this number 4,050 received out-door relief, 1,353 were inmates of the work- house, and 276 inmates of the infirmary?total, 1,629. The number of sick visited at their homes during that year was above the average, amounting to 3,156. Average daily number receiving medical relief was?patients in tlie infirmary, 230 ; patients visited at home, 136 ; prescribed for at the infirmary, 163 ; workhouse patients, 102?total, 631, being I in 220 of the population, and above 12 per cent, of the paupers.
Table of 14,541 Patients treated at their own Homes and in the St. Marylebone Infirmary. Diseases Nervous system Respiratory organs Vascular system, heart, &c. Genito- ) urinary organs j Digest: vo organs Where treated Homo Infirmary Home Infirmary Homo Infirmary Homo Infirmary Homo Infirmary Locomotive organs and [ cellular tissue > Fevers Home Infirmary Homo Infirmary Totals . “Winter Quarter Males 335 196 Fern. 11-1 135 Spring Quarter Males 469 216 104 66 239 127 238 240 220 108 1,725 67 128 145 61 223 246 318 117 2,409 196 168 193 105 Fern. 100 142 303 130 101 46 1,421 48 126 131 79 Summer Quarter Males 197 248 290 131 2,075 134 101 Fem. 92 121 134 103 110 52 152 200 232 57 68 94 185 89 147 201 - Autumn Quarter Males Fem. 214 156 113 44 173 256 291 92 1,297 1,779 226 85 109 113 295 188 107 59 60 120 178 71 Age?Years Under 7 100 28 484 195 191 79 222 146 273 296 149 364 845 211 1,568 2,240 2,781 7 to 20 119 92 230 135 108 79 90 176 20 to 45 252 398 775 424 285 97 207 317 121 77 238 635 428 233 2,761 464 188 623 398 562 247 45 and upwards 162 326 634 463 190 141 34 59 233 160 541 435 231 156 5,237 3,765 Besults Cured 287 336 1,193 400 287 107 230 484 805 387 1,212 1,531 1,609 712 Relieved 89 353 408 324 178 136 61 48 89 48 103 218 67 9,580 2,977 Dead 70 155 236 493 67 142 No of Males 218 333 Fem. Cases treated 415 511 922 580 213 162 131 80 1,607 102 88 370 204 759 864 871 355 6,041 1,201 637 422 223 243 468 639 300 789 968 1,195 492 8,403 446 844 1,837 1,217 532 385 296 556 930 504 1,331 1,832 1,807 847 13,444 Proportion o? Deaths to Cases treated 1 in 6 4 1 in 5*4 1 in 7-7 1 in 25 1 in 8 1 in 2-7 1 in 47 1 in 22-8 1 in 25 1 in 73 1 in 73 1 in 22 1 in 13 8 1 in 10”5
1,180 of these’ Home’ cases were removed to the Infirmary, Small-Pox, Fever Hospitals, &c. In the table, which is a summary of the statistical tables, published for three years, of the diseases of the out-door poor visited at their homes and those admitted to the infirmary, the diseases of the two classes in separate lines are arranged under seven heads, distinguishing the sexes, numbers in each quarter (winter, spring, summer, and autumn), at four periods of life; the results are also shown and the mortality in cases stated.
The total numbers in the two classes of each sex, were: From diseases of the nervous system 551 males 926 females. ,, ,, respiratory organs 1,502 ? 1,838 ? ,, ? vascular system 375 ,, 545 ? ? ? digestive organs 574 ? 939 ? ? ,, genito-urinary do. 190 ,, 711 ? ? ,, locomotive organs & cellular tissue 1,623 ,, 1,757 ? ? ? eruptive and other fevers 1,226 ? 1,687 ? Total 6,041 ,, 8,503 ?
Attention was drawn to some singular facts that presented themselves on looking at the different classes of diseases. It was observed that the females far outnumbered the males, and that the mortality among the females was lower. The pre- ponderance in females was 1*8 per cent, in diseases of the ner- vous system, hysteria having been exclusively confined to them. The diseases of the digestive organs were 1*3 per cent., and the genito-urinary 4*9 per cent, more in females than in males. This disproportion depended mainly on the more frequent occurrence of inflammatory affections of those organs in the female than the male. The diseases of the vascular system fell more heavily on the females than the males, being 1*3 per cent, more in the former than in the latter. To some extent this was owing to derangement in menstruation; and so far as concerns the heart, the preponderance was owing to affections of that organ being less frequently complicated with disease of the respiratory organs in women than in men. Dropsy was more frequent amongst females.
The diseases of the respiratory organs preponderated in males, being 3*3 per cent, more than in females, the mortality was also higher in males than in females. Diseases of the locomotive organs and cellular tissue, as might be expected, were more frequent in males, being 6*1 per cent, more than in females. Fever seemed to affect both sexes almost indifferently. Effect of season upon particular diseases was very remarkable. The warmth of summer was most favourable to diseases of the nervous system ; there were fewest cases at that season. In the diseases of the respiratory organs the numbers had fallen off two-thirds in those visited at home in the summer compared with the winter months. There was no great difference in diseases of the vascular system; but diseases of the digestive organs were most numerous in summer and autumn. As regards age, it was observed that diseases of the nervous system were most numerous between twenty and forty-five, but the greatest mortality occurred after that period. In the diseases of the respiratory organs the prevalence was greatest after forty-five, but the mortality was enormous in infancy. It was stated: ” this fact is so striking, that if returns from other institutions correspond with the present, it will call loudly for the necessity of excluding young children from crowded establishments in large towns.” The London parochial schools have since been moved to the country.
Diseases of the vascular system prevailed most in adult and in advanced life, and were most fatal at the latter period. Diseases of the locomotive organs and cellular tissue were distributed pretty equally over the three first periods. Fevers of the eruptive kind were most fatal in female children. In the original tables the diseases were arranged under upwards of sixty different heads, which have here been sum- marised under seven heads.
With respect to the diseases of the nervous system there were ten subdivisions, viz. neuralgia, hysteria, delirium tremens, convulsions, epilepsy, insanity, inflammation of the brain and membranes, chronic diseases of these organs, apoplexy, and paralysis.
The organic diseases amounted to 43 and the others to 57 per cent., nearly.
Middle-aged persons were found to be most frequently the subjects of what has been termed the functional diseases, except convulsions, which principally attacked and proved fatal to infants. Convulsions, too, like insanity, appear to have an hereditary tendency; in confirmation of which the following cases occurred in the lying-in ward, viz. the death of two newly-born children, the offspring of epileptic women, and the death of another from the same cause, its mother at the time suffering from puerperal mania. Again, a girl aged 11 years, was brought, in an epileptic fit, to the infirmary; her mother stating that two of her four children had died from con- vulsions, and that she herself was subject to epilepsy. These cases, which all came under notice within a short period, would seem to confirm the opinion that there is a connection and hereditary tendency between convulsions, epilepsy, and insanity. The connection between symptoms and organic lesions in cerebral diseases has ever been one of the utmost difficulty and obscurity. The severest symptoms have occurred without com- mensurate, or, indeed, any structural change being discovered; and, on the other hand, extensive disease has been found with- out any or but slight symptoms.
As in almost all the cases I have recorded the state of each of the organs, if different from health, as well as the weight and the relations of each in various diseases and in both sexes, are compared, it appears necessary here to give the average weights, which, as taken from the cases examined in the Somerset County Asylum, showed the following results :?
Age Sex 20 to 40 ( M- years { M. 40 to 60 ? I F. Body lbs. cz. ft. in. 07 4 15 6 77 12 5 3 109 0 79 12 5 7 5 2 Measurement of head in. 22-1 ! 13-2 21-2 ‘ 12-8 22-2 ; 13 21*4 12-9 13 2 13 13 3 12-7 Cerebral Organs Cerebrum P3 3 O) H oz. 20-3 18-9 19-9 18-3 oz. 20-4 5-2 19-1 ! 4-8 20 2 5-4 18-5 4-7 47-1 43-8 46-6 43-2 oz. 11 1 Thoracic Organs oz. 26 19 M 27-9 ?9 18-5 oz. 23 18 24 16 oz. 9 3 7-6 109 8-7 Abdominal Organs oz. 5-6 5 oz. 52-7 44’5 oz. 5-2 52 5 43 oz. 35 3 36 3 oz. 43 4-1 45 4-2 oz. 5 4-3 -7 15 5-4 -9 4-2 -7 1-7 Upwards] of 60 | -p 107 9 5 6 88 7 | 5 2 22-3 21-3 13-3 12-8 13-2 13 19-96 19-98 5-1 17’9 18-12 4 8 11 | 46-1 ?95 41-6 1 23 ?9 16 20 15 5’4 49 3-4 3-6 31 28 48 36 4-6 3-5 -8 15
Effects of Age upon the Weight of the Organs. From a comparison of the organs in the first and third periods of life, a diminution of their weight in the latter is evident. This would seem in great measure to be dependent on age, as it has almost invariably been found greatest in persons farthest advanced in life. In the third period the diminution of the weight of the encephalon was one ounce in the male and one and a half ounce in the female; tlie- decrease was confined to the cerebrum in the male, but in the female there was a slight decrease in the pons and medulla. The heart was an exception, as in males of the third period it was two and three quarters and in females nearly two and a half ounces heavier, which may be owing to the great mortality of pulmonary diseases, which are usually combined with enlarged heart.
Weights of the organs in the male and female compared,, show a general diminution of their weight in the latter; in the encephalon the difference is 3*3 in the first and 4-5 ounces in the last period, chiefly in the cerebral hemispheres, the- difference being 2 ounces in the right and 1*8 in the left. The left cerebral hemisphere was about one-eighth in the males and one-fourth of an ounce in the females heavier than the right; the cerebellum nearly half an ounce heavier in males than in females; the pons and medulla alike in both sexes at the three periods. The difference in the weight of the heart increased with age, being but one and three quarters in the first period and three ounces less at the third period in the female than in the male.
The organic diseases of the brain arranged under?1st,, inflammatory affections of the membranes of the brain and of the spinal marrow; 2nd, softening of the brain, which is supposed to be in most cases, but not always, a result of in- flammation ; 3rd, tuberculous, cancerous, and other tumours of the brain; 4tli, apoplexy and paralysis. These diseases have been found most frequent in infancy and in advanced age, and formed about three-fourths of the fatal cases of disease of the brain in the St. Marylebone Infirmary. The functional diseases include the remaining fourth. These are convulsions, epilepsy, and insanity, in contradistinction to the organic dis- eases, because it frequently happens that no structural change whatever is observable in the cerebro-spinal system, or any appreciable difference from what is seen in the brains and spinal cords of persons free from those disorders.
The term spasm was applied by Dr Cullen to a state of muscular contraction more violent than is usual in health. Where the contraction is succeeded by relaxation, and imme- diately repeated without the concurrence of the will or from natural causes, he applies the term convulsions. Dr Cop- land, in his Dictionary, has given a fuller definition to dis- tinguish convulsions from allied aud specific diseases, as tetanus &c. Andral’s definition is similar to Copland’s, with this addition, that there is not loss of consciousness. When there is loss of consciousness the disease is termed eclampsia, always without foaming at the mouth, by which eclampsia is distinguished from epilepsy.
Animals hanged and bled to death die convulsed. A state of general plethora, or an opposite state, anaemia, are both favourable to convulsions. Hippocrates asserted that con- vulsions were brought on either from repletion or inanition. Gralen also considered these two the chief causes, but added a third, irritation, which is by some referred to repletion, and for this state blisters were considered the fitting remedy. Hoff- man says the membranes of the spinal cord are affected in convulsions. Morgani (letter x) treats of convulsions, and, amongst other causes, mentions disease of the kidneys. Boerhave mentions that in cases of great debility spasms and convulsions are wont to precede death, and in animals from fatal haemorrhage and from overdose of some vegetable poisons. Copland mentions an epidemic of convulsions that occurred in the West of Scotland in 1742, from hearing addresses directed to the imagination and passions of their hearers by the followers of Whitfield. Another epidemic in Cornwall, in 1813-14, from similar causes, is described by Mr. Cornish. Dr Babington, in his admirable preface to his translation of Hecker’s History of the Epidemics of the Middle Ages, well observes, “that the mind and the body reciprocally and mysteriously affect each other, and the maladies which are the subject of these pages are so inti- mately connected with the disordered state of both that it is often difficult to determine on which they more essentially depend, or which they more seriously influence.” Joy will affect the circulation, grief the digestion; anger will heat the frame as perniciously as ardent spirits, and fear will chill it as certainly as ice. Specific diseases, too, are produced through the agency of mental impressions. The dances of St. John and St. Vitus, as they formerly spread from city to city, gave rise to the same deviations from bodily health in all the individuals they attacked. The dancing mania called tarantism was the same disease, whether medically or morally considered, all over Italy; it was, at its greatest height in tlie seventeenth century, caused by the bite of a venomous spider. Nothing but music afforded relief. This disease continued for nearly four hundred years. A similar disease in Abyssinia is described as seen in 1819.* In France the ” convulsionnaires” appeared in 1737, and continued to the revolution, 1790. Nervous disorders in an epidemic form exist at the pre- sent time both in Europe and America. Their appearance in single cases leads to the belief that they also proceed from physical causes, which is supported in experiments of modern physiologists.
We also find that convulsions attend almost every variety of organic disease of the brain. In the writings of Bonetus cases are mentioned where there was foetid discharge from the nostrils; another where there was serum in the cerebrum and spinal canal; another where serum was found in the cerebral ventricles; another from fracture of the skull; another from effusion of urine, &c. I have observed convulsions in adults attend cancerous tumours in the brain, also granular disease of the kidneys, enlarged kidneys and heart, dropsy, and enlarge- ment of the brain.
A case of this nature occurred in the St. Marylebone Infirmary (No. 784), a coachman, aged 50, admitted twelve days before death with hemiplegia of the right side of six months’ duration. After admission he had several convulsive fits; twitchings of the muscles of the face ; the face was flushed. He was dull in comprehending and slow in answering questions. He became suddenly worse, and for the last five days of his life was unable to speak. The structure of the brain was softened and adherent to the dura mater, which was thickened; attached to it were several scirrhous tumours of various sizes, from a pin’s head to a large pea.
Another case (No. 839) of a man, aged 36, under treat- ment in the infirmary for seven weeks: convulsions, combined with enlarged heart, kidneys, and liver, and general dropsy. The convulsions came on seven hours previous to death. Head: Some blood effused in the scalp ; brain large and pale; convolutions flattened ; pia mater readily peeled off’; no fluid in the ventricles ; weight of the enceplialon 52 oz. Chest: About 1 pint of fluid in the pleura; general bronchitis; oedema of lower lobe ; right lung 4Uoz., left lung 26i oz.; heart much enlarged and mitral valves thickened, weight 18^-oz. Abdo- men : Some fluid in peritoneum ; liver large, 82 oz.; kidneys enlarged, 15^ oz.; body 153 lbs.; length 5 ft. 10 in. Case in a * Life of Xath. Pearce. female aged 62 (No. 842) : convulsions, combined with wasted and granular kidneys. Head: Brain large, 48^ oz. Chest : Lungs natural, heart large, 11^oz. Abdomen: Mucous fol- licles of stomach unusually large, 6 oz.; kidneys wasted, granular, right 3tj oz., left only H oz.; body 73 lbs. Another case (No. 843) in a female aged 69 : convulsions, with pain in the loins and suppression of urine. Head: Brain 38^ oz., soft. Chest: Lungs natural; heart 10^ oz. Abdomen: Liver small, 30 oz.; kidneys dark coloured and soft.
Children born with large heads, strumous habits, fine white skin, the muscular system little developed, and subject to diarrhoea, are prone to convulsions. Convulsions have also suc- ceeded an eruption on the head, and often occur during dentition. Valsalva observed that the external figure of the cerebrum, which follows the figure of the skull, when it is not natural may indicate something entirely foreign to the intentions of nature which renders it prone to disease.
Convulsions may terminate in some of the diseases of the brain, or in death, and death may occur either by the brain, the lungs, or heart, as shown in the foregoing cases. Andral found, in fatal cases of convulsions, frequently lesions of the brain, varying in extent from simple hyperemia even to extensive softenings ; but in many instances no lesion was discovered, and such cases he sets down to irritation.
The symptoms of convulsions may occur during the course of any other disease or in a state of perfect health and leave not a trace behind. They consist of various movements?bend- ing of fingers and toes, shaking of the head. Strong emotions in infancy, as fright, anger, are predisposing causes. The children of epileptic persons often die in convulsions, and the records of lunatic asylums show that those of their children who survive often become epileptics and insane. In six infants who died from convulsions, four males and two females, whom I examined within a short period, two males and two females were from one to four weeks old, and two males were eight and eleven months respectively. In one male infant the convulsions lasted five days, in the other male the convulsions were of shorter duration. In one female the convulsions continued nearly from birth, and in the other female for ten days. Head : In three males and one female the cerebral vessels were congested with blood; in one male the brain was unusually large; in one female the brain was in a normal state. Chest: The lungs were congested with blood or hepatised in all the six infants ; in one male the ” foramen ovale ” of the heart and the ” ductus arteriosus ” were open. Abdomen: In one male the viscera were unusually pale; in one male the mesenteric glands were enlarged. Case of Scrofula and Waxy Liver, terminating in Convulsions.
Michael Q., aged 18, admitted October 17, 1846, from the Margate Infirmary, where he had been for caries of the spine, backward curvature, and a scrofulous abscess in the loins. Coming back from Margate in the steamer he had a fit of convulsions, which recurred frequently after his return; he died January 12, 1847. During the last two days he was delirious. Head: Brain unusually large, pale, convolutions flattened, right cerebral hemisphere, 22; left, 23 ; cerebellum, 5?; pons and medulla, 1 ; encephalon, 51^. The right optic thalamus weighed in this case siijss, the left siijss 9i; the right corpus striatum, f oz. siss, left f oz. si; the corpora quadri- gemina, 5iss. Chest: Right lung, 7f ; left, 7 ; heart small, 4foz. There were pleuritic adhesions at the apices of lungs, and a few tubercles and small anfractuous ulcerations in the right, the left lung pale, structure natural; the heart filled with pale fibrine. Abdomen : The liver enormously enlarged, which was evident during life, waxy, weight, 81f; stomach, 2f; spleen, 10?; pancreas, 2; kidneys large; right, 5; left, 6 ; renal capsules, b ; mucous membrane of intestines natural; caries of ischium. Mr. Gulliver found the portion of liver the colour of crude bees-wax, and stiff or tenuerous in texture ; from his examination by the microscope these characters appeared to be owing to an unusual accumulation in the liver of viscid biliary matter, with a large proportion of mucus. It did not contain more fatty matter than in the healthy state.
Convulsive motions of the eyes, which are sometimes turned upwards and at others inwards or outwards, contortions of the face, contractions of abdominal and thoracic muscles, and spasm of the diaphragm producing’ hiccup; the tongue is sometimes protruded at others retracted ; the involuntary muscles, as the heart, are seized with palpitation, and the peristaltic actions increased in the intestines. Sometimes there is vomiting and involuntary dejections.
The convulsions are either general, which is rare, or partial,, which is common. Irregular muscular motions are not the only symptoms; there is also incomplete and sometimes complete loss of consciousness.
The muscles after violent convulsions often become painful, ecchymosis is sometimes produced, or even dislocations, rupture of tendons, and even sometimes fractures. The duration is. variable. There is a tendency to recurrence. The recurrence of convulsions has been known to have ceased after vaccination. Convulsive affections are sometimes the effects of injury. Solly, in his work on the human brain, page 561, gives a most interesting case of a man, aged 33, who received a compound fracture of the skull. For thirteen days after admission to St. Thomas’ Hospital he had no bad symptoms. Pain and throbbing in the head came on, followed, after two days’ duration, by a fit and hemiplegia in the left side. Fits next day became frequent, loss of consciousness followed, and death seventeen days after the accident. The brain corresponding to the fracture was dis- coloured and disorganised downwards into the lateral ventricle, and the arachnoid covered with pus on the injured hemisphere only.
As to the treatment, no uniform plan can be adopted; it must entirely be regulated and guided by the causes. The diet and regimen ought to be carefully attended to. In infants and young children crying should be prevented, if possible, as it often brings back the seizures. When the bowels have been sufficiently evacuated, the ” hydrargyrum cum creta ” is recommended; blood-letting and evacuants in cases depend- ing on plethora, and the very opposite treatment in cases depending on anaemia. Narcotics are sometimes indicated; also ammonia, ether, tincture of castor, or tincture of sumbul, quinine, nitrate of bismuth, and oxide of zinc are sometimes given. Purgatives are sometimes required, and oil of turpen- tine, if worms are supposed to exist. Warm or vapour baths, or fomentations in case of a suppressed eruption, may be found “beneficial. Blisters and sinapisms, as counter-irritants, are often applicable.
Disclaimer
The historical material in this project falls into one of three categories for clearances and permissions:
Material currently under copyright, made available with a Creative Commons license chosen by the publisher.
Material that is in the public domain
Material identified by the Welcome Trust as an Orphan Work, made available with a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
While we are in the process of adding metadata to the articles, please check the article at its original source for specific copyrights.